Skip to content
Call Now To Schedule An Asset Protection Analysis: (800) 231-7112

In the last two articles on this series regarding strategic default, we discussed the financial considerations and consequences of actively choosing to let a mortgage go into foreclosure, and we discussed the general conditions leading up to our current situation.  This article is a continuation of the second article, Strategic Default: How We Got Here.

As we discussed in first article on strategic default, it makes sense financially to walk away from a mortgage when the balance owed is more than the underlying property is worth.  But what are the consequences, and is it morally right?  The very short answer (in this author’s opinion) is yes, very often it is morally right to walk away.

Lender’s Are Equally At Fault for Strategic Defaults

moralitySetting aside lender fraud (things like lying on mortgage applications), the truth of the matter is that lenders chose to eliminate safeguards such as requiring a 20% down payment from borrowers.  Now it’s true that many borrowers took advantage of the system and became speculators, but banks and other lending institutions knew it was happening and continued lending.  The worst part of the story is that banks and lenders also knew that a meltdown could occur.  Other markets that entertain speculators are strictly regulated.  However, the strict regulations do not apply to real estate speculation.  Banks and other lending institutions saw an easy way to make a ton of profit by extending credit, and they chose to ignore the known risks of a “real estate bubble.”  “Bubble” is a term that just refers to unreasonably high prices, and when a bubble bursts, prices plummet.

Unlike you and me, when the real estate bubble popped, the federal government bailed out the banks, even though the banks knew all about the risks they were taking.  And that, to me, is the real difference between the banks and real estate speculators: Banks knew without a doubt that they were helping to create a bubble.  Some real estate speculators knew too, but they were not in a position to stop it.  A speculator can only choose to participate or not to participate.  Banks, on the other hand, could have required 20% down payments.  They could have tightened lending standards.

Those Considering Strategic Defaults are Victims

The bottom line is that unless you were aware of all of the above and all, it’s quite possible that you are a victim of the greatest scam of all time–a scam that allowed banks to take huge risks and get bailed out when their bets failed.  In light of that, how could it be immoral to walk away from a bad, underwater loan?

If that’s not enough, here’s another moral reason to walk away: It will help normalize the market.  By holding on to an underwater property, you are signaling that you believe the property is worth at least as much as is owed on it, even if you know the contrary.  By allowing such a property to go into foreclosure, the market can find the correct supply and demand equilibrium and establish prices that reflect true value.  Even more importantly, current lending regulations make loans more difficult to obtain, so you would essentially be trading a “bad,” speculation-prone mortgage into a “good,” long-term asset.

As one final observation, I have had discussions with a number of attorneys who have told me many of their clients with strategic defaults on their credit records are suffering minimal adverse consequences in terms of finding new lines of credit or gaining employment, because foreclosures are now so widespread and commonplace.  Just something to keep in mind . . . .

This Post Has 0 Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pashmina Lalchandani

CEO & Co-Founder, Bar & Cocoa / Owner, Flow Simple
December 9, 2010, Douglass was a client of Pashmina’s

I’ve known Doug in many contexts, as a friend, as a client and as a business partner and he impresses me on all levels. He’s dependable, smart, generous and I wouldn’t hesitate recommending him and his law firm to anyone.
He’s the best and most ethical lawyers providing asset protection with rock solid strategies to give you peace of mind about your wealth. Straight forward, and straight talk. Doug is exactly the lawyer I want on my side. If I send someone to Doug, I know they’ll thank me for it!

Social & Solar Entrepreneur, Pan Afrikan Theorist, Translator/Interpreter,
Founder & Visionary Leader @ Afrikanpride.
March 12, 2011, Marlon E. D. J. worked with Douglass but at different companies

Doug is one of the most powerful thinker i have came across. During the short time that i have known Doug he has been a great source of inspiration. He has a simplistic yet effective and accurate way to analyze anything you bring to his attention, and then by asking you key questions he gets you to see the light at the end of the tunnel. Besides being extremely bright, he is a genuine and caring individual which is why I feel fortunate to know him. I can say without a doubt that he his the person you would want to talk to if you were in need of a person with his expertise.
Most of the lawyers out there will probably meet your needs, but if you are looking for someone to exceed your expectations and give you that wow factor, look no more he is the person for the job.

Patricia Salter

Associate Dentist at Smileology
December 1, 2010, Patricia was a client of Douglass’

I have been a client of Douglas Lodmell’s since 2001. My main concern was asset protection in this litigious society. I can sleep alot better at night knowing I have the instruments in place to protect the fruits of my labor, and that they will not end up in the hands of a slick trial attorney.

Corporate Transparency Act

Stay compliant with the Corporate Transparency Act.
Report your business entities easily through FinCEN’s streamlined process.

Contact Us Today to Schedule an Asset Protection Analysis.

800-231-7112

Back To Top